Jails in Crisis: Study Identifies Those at Risk of Suicide Behind Bars
Threatening or attempting suicide and/or self-harm were seven times greater for those in protective custody versus those in the general population.
In the United States, jails handle about 11.7 million admissions each year. Jails are, generally, the place where individuals are arrested for crimes ranging from vagrancy to murder and are booked and held until their court appearances – the average stay is about 23 days.
In America’s jails, suicide is the leading cause of death – the rate of suicide is nearly three times higher in jails than in prisons or the general public. Estimates show that there are 80 suicide attempts for every fatal suicide within a correctional facility. About 40 percent of deaths occur within the first seven days of admission to jail.
Despite the gravity and extent of the problem in correctional institutions and jails specifically, very little attention has been directed at understanding the factors associated with suicide and self-harm (SSH) among jail detainees. Understanding the correlates of suicide risk in jails is essential to build a profile of individuals who may be at more risk for suicide while in custody.
A study by Florida Atlantic University’s College of Social Work and Criminal Justice is the first to examine the risk factors for attempting and threatening SSH among 736 males and females during incarceration in a large metropolitan jail in the Midwest using logistic regression and the lens of “Interpersonal Theory of Suicide” (ITS). ITS suggests three risk factors responsible for suicide: acquired capability for suicide; thwarted belongingness (isolation and loneliness); and perceived burdensomeness (burden to other people).
“Researchers have long recognized the shock and lack of control associated with circumstances and surroundings in jail such as disorientation, abrupt separation from social support and society, and the degree of degradation and interpersonal conflict that arise from being incarcerated,” said Calli Cain, Ph.D., senior author and an assistant professor in FAU’s School of Criminology and Criminal Justice. “However, the extent to which these experiences culminate in a propensity for suicide and self-harm remains understudied.”
Results of the study, published in the journal , showed:
- Threatening and/or attempting SSH were seven times greater for those in protective custody versus those in the general population. Individuals had a similar risk of SSH regardless of their level of family support, marital status, or if they had a visitor in the past month.
- Threatening SSH was 61 percent greater for inmates who were in jail for the first time. Odds of self-harming behaviors were similar regardless of disposition status.
- Threatening and/or attempting SSH was 64 percent lower for males versus females. Individuals had a similar risk of SSH regardless of their age or race.
- Attempting SSH was twice as high as for those with substance dependence issues compared to those without.
- Threatening and/or attempting suicide more than doubled for each violent incident they witnessed in jail. For each one unit increase in the psychological distress scale, the odds of threatening and/or attempting SSH increased by about 180 percent.
- Threatening or attempting SSH more than doubled when individuals were homeless prior to admission, while their odds of threatening and/or attempting SSH increased by 4 percent with each additional admission. Employment status had no effect on whether individuals engaged in SSH behaviors while in jail.
- The odds of threatening SSH were nearly two and a half times greater for individuals who were assaulted by another detainee, and their odds of attempting SSH were more than double those who failed to mention any victimization.
For the study, researchers asked individuals how many times in the past three months of their most recent incarceration they had threatened SSH, and how many times in the past year of their most recent incarceration they had attempted .
Results showed that 6.7 percent of the sample said they had threatened SSH in jail during the past three months, 4.5 percent said they had attempted SSH in jail during the past year, and 8.4 percent said they had threatened and/or attempted SSH in the past three months or one year. This is much higher than the rate of attempted suicide in the general population (0.6 percent).
“The reality is that many more individuals attempt, contemplate, or threaten suicide prior to a fatal suicide attempt in a jail setting, and self-harming behaviors may be a risk factor or precursor for more serious attempts on one’s life,” said Cain. “The high rate of suicide in our jails over the last 20 years also suggests that the conventional approach of isolating individuals such as on suicide watch who admit to or are suspected of wanting to hurt themselves is insufficient, especially since most individuals who die by suicide in jail are not on suicide watch at the time of their passing.”
Findings from the study could assist administrators and jail personnel in recognizing the warning signs and prevent suicide, improve institutional safety, and limit legal liability. It also supports the need for jails to develop an empirically and theoretically driven suicidal risk assessment – especially one that includes indicators of thwarted belongingness and perceived burdensomeness.
Study co-author is Jared M. Ellison, Ph.D., an assistant professor of sociology and criminal justice at Old Dominion University.
-FAU-